Christina McNamara
left her home on John Street for St. Mary’s chapel shortly after eight o’clock on the night of 18th of February
1899. As she was walking down Broad Street a few minutes later, she would have watched
as some boys who had gathered on the footpath blocking the way being ordered to
move on by Acting Sergeant Doherty. She continued down Broad Street towards Ball’s
bridge passing Mr Shine’s house when a loud crash was heard. The Acting Sergeant
and others on the street turned suddenly round they saw a cloud of dust rising from
the footpath where the girl had been. At the same time, bricks were seen falling
from the wall of Mr Shine’s three-storey house. The roof, which had large flags
on it, and upper portion of the house, had collapsed about forty feet to the ground.
It was after
the dust cleared that the girl was spotted on the ground partly covered in debris
with a large flagstone on her legs. It was thought at the time that she had died
at the scene but she remained alive although unconscious until five o’clock the following morning. Three boys were
also pulled from the rubble but their injuries were not thought to have been life
threatening.
The house was
at least a few hundred years old and seemed least likely of all the houses in the
street to fall. A notice was sent to the occupiers of the house that the building
was in a dangerous state but this letter was dated the 20th of February
two days after the accident. Mr. Shine lived in the portion of the house that collapsed;
he rented it from a Miss Mary Griffin. Mr Shine stated that he did not feel that
there was anything wrong with the roof apart from a leak and as Miss Griffin had
replaced the rafters only thirteen years before he considered it safe.
A rider was
issued during the inquest into the girls death stating; “that in view of the danger
to lives of residents and the public generally having business in John street, Mungret
street and Broad street and the old town generally, we beg to call attention to
owners of property and other responsible officials of the insecure state of the
same and their dilapidated condition in said area”.
Many of the
houses on the street had used props to support the walls in the small lanes off
the main street. It was believed that if these props were removed that the entire
house, which it supported, would collapse. Some of these props were still in place in the 1950, as seen in the picture above.
Two years earlier
in February 1897 a similar house on John Street completely collapsed in on itself.
Click on thumbnail for larger image
top